See all books by Ferdinand von Schirach. Product Details. Inspired by Your Browsing History. Related Articles. Looking for More Great Reads? Download our Spring Fiction Sampler Now. Download Hi Res. LitFlash The eBooks you want at the lowest prices. Read it Forward Read it first. Pass it on! But, as Schirach writes, the prosecutor feels there isn't enough evidence to reopen the case. I hope that helps. See 2 questions about Crime and Guilt…. Lists with This Book.
- Account Options.
- ASHES: a story about cigarettes, cremation and hope.
- AUTHORITY STEALING: How Greedy Politicians and Corporate Executives Loot the World’s Most Populous Black Nation.
- Dont Tread on Me: The Tea Party Revolution.
Community Reviews. Showing Rating details. More filters. Sort order. Jan 23, Jill rated it really liked it. What is guilt anyway? Ferdinand von Schirach — a leading German defense attorney and the grandson of Baldur von Schirach, head of the Hitler Youth and convicted at Nuremberg — has no doubt pondered the nature of guilt in all its manifestations more than most of us.
Here, he showcases 15 stories based on real cases, exploring the gray and not-so-gray meanings of guilt. His vignettes are written in a sparse, straightforward, sometimes clinical tone — think Ray Carver, for example. The simplicity of the style belies the emotional power that hides behind it.
One senses there are two von Schirachs: the dispassionate and professional defense attorney who has learned to carefully cull the facts and another one, who might be shaking his head in amazement. The author presents a diversity of cases, which could have been mere file cases in the hands of a lesser author, and presents what guilt and its impact mean to the perpetrator and those who are closest to him or her. I will say that the author — and his translator, Carol Brown Janeway — have, through an economy of words, created mesmerizing portrayals that provide a whiplash despite the laconic style.
View all 6 comments. Not only was that good, but it led me to this splendid double volume of two books of short stories. From von Schirach's professional engagement with the law in Germany, he has crafted some beautifully written and very well translated by Carol Brown Janeway insights into the German legal system and, more importantly, the strange, terrible and bizarre ways in which we come up against the law and c I'm really pleased that I picked up a copy of The Collini Case while waiting for a train in London. From von Schirach's professional engagement with the law in Germany, he has crafted some beautifully written and very well translated by Carol Brown Janeway insights into the German legal system and, more importantly, the strange, terrible and bizarre ways in which we come up against the law and criminals.
Many of the stories are little gems, some are painfully sad, others hilarious. All are exquisitely written. A real treat. The only problem is the temptation to read too many at once. They are to be savoured. Jan 10, Kally Sheng rated it it was amazing Shelves: ferdinand-von-schirach , favorites.
My subject is human beings - their failings, their guilt, and their capacity to behave magnificently. All our lives we dance on a thin layer of ice; it's very cold underneath, and death is quick.
After Committing a Crime, Guilt and Shame Predict Re-Offense
The ice won't bear the weight of some people and they fall through. That's the moment that interests me.
If we're lucky, it never happens to us and we keep dancing. If we're lucky. Heisenberg, Pg.
Crime and Guilt - Ferdinand Von Schirach - Google книги
And most often, it's also what's right. We believe we know something for sure, we get carried away, and it's often far from simple to find our way back. Jun 04, Mike Barnett rated it really liked it. Very stark and understated stories about some truly gruesome crimes. Sort of a modernist Grimm's tales Sep 09, Ann Ackermann rated it liked it Shelves: crime. He purportedly writes about his own cases and clients. For the story structure and prose, the book deserves five stars. In the book description on the inside of the front cover, the reader is promised these are true stories. That could be possible if the author obtained from his clients a release from the attorney-client privilege.
The claim made the book especially interesting to me because I used to practice criminal law in the U.
- ‘Guilt,’ Stories by Ferdinand von Schirach - The New York Times;
- Strangers at My Door: A True Story of Finding Jesus in Unexpected Guests.
- Mental Man or (How Love Saved Me From The Jehovahs Witnesses).
- Die Machttheorie von Michel Foucault (German Edition);
- Probably True Paranormal Stories: Bologna or Not? Vol. III.
Pretty early on, it became clear that the stories are made up. At one point he even gives us the last thoughts of a homicide victim as he dies — even though the victim never spoke. That had to be fictionalized. In a interview with the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung newspaper , Schirach insisted the stories were true.
Schirach explained the case never made the newspaper, a claim I find extremely dubious. I wish Schirach had been honest with his readers from the beginning and told us these are fictional stories based on his experiences as a criminal defense lawyer.
Ferdinand von Schirach
A monitoring video caught the event. The hotel never changed the video clock from summertime to wintertime, and in cross examination, the protagonist defense attorney points out the time stamp is wrong — his client left the hotel the day after the time change. He confuses the witness, gets him to admit it must have been an hour earlier, and on that basis, makes a motion to dismiss the case.
Once the judge realizes the mistake, the attorney will have lost credibility in future cases. Credibility is a precious commodity. Just as attorneys can lose their credibility in court, authors can lose their credibility with their readers. Jul 01, IsabelleAnna rated it really liked it Shelves: school-reads , short-stories. Makes you realise that crime and its consequences are not two-dimensional, but have depth that goes beyond initial impression. Feb 18, Keirstan rated it really liked it Shelves: short-stories , read-in What a great concept for a book! Ferdinand von Schirach is one of Germany's premier defense attorneys and has crafted a collection of short stories based on his experiences.
As an admitted lover of true crime and an avid DVRer of Dateline, the stories themselves gripped me from the outset as evidenced by the day and a half it took me to read them! What surprised me, however, was the quality and insight of the collection. Von Schirach gets at the root of what makes his clients human, sussing o What a great concept for a book! Von Schirach gets at the root of what makes his clients human, sussing out their motives despite the heinous crimes they are accused of.
And on top of that, von Schirach is a fabulous writer! Here's hoping to his continued career in writing. Oct 28, Anna rated it really liked it Shelves: mystery-crime-scary , i-recommend , isms. F v S is a defense attorney but apparently also a gifted writer with a bare, very precise language. These short stories of criminal cases - written as short stories - are so witty, others were simply heartbreakening. Jun 24, Ursula rated it it was amazing.
These diverse short stories make for a very interesting read.
Von Schirach suggests that anyone could become a criminal and these stories would illustrate that point. The story Fahner, in particular, is about your everyday doctor who turns murderer because he is pushed to far. In the afterword to his first collection, von Schirach compares the two systems with characteristic perspective and detachment.
Tell us what you think. Please upgrade your browser. See next articles. Translated by Carol Brown Janeway. Alfred A. News World U.